
Released: 2008 – Label: anticon.
Why? is an “indie hip-hop” from Oakland, and part of the anticon. collective, a group of artists who release albums that they define as “avante-garde hip-hop”, so basically hip-hop that doesn’t sound like hip-hop but still has the makings of it. Very complicated stuff. Well, at least I made it sound that way. Why? is made up of Yoni Wolf (previously in cLOUDDEAD), Doug McDiarmid, Austin Brown, and Yoni’s brother Josiah Wolf, and they create a sound that is very unique. As stated above, they mix indie-rock with Yoni’s unique style of “rapping”, which is more sung than actually rapped. It’s very hard to describe Why?, but I’ll give it a go.
Alopecia is one of those rare occurances that happens once every so often, in which the album does not have a bad song on it, and that every song is accessible, no matter what type of music you like. Yoni has a unique way of writing, combining direct, confrontational lyrics with his own (and I hate myself for saying this) quirky metaphors, as well as the subjects he writes about. Combined with the perfectly fitting music, created with a mix of guitars, pianos, drums, keyboards, various different percussion instruments, household objects, xylophones and at one point even a bell, they are as much indie as they are hip-hop. All the sound is created by the band, which is fairly unheard of in hip-hop these days. There’s some rock tracks, there’s some hip-hop tracks, there’s some heartwrenching tracks. And it’s wonderful, from start to finish.
The album opens up with The Vowels Pt. 2, a twinkling piano, a mix of rhythmic percussion and lots of guitar. On first listening, this is the furthest thing from hip-hop, until Yoni kicks in with his unique voice, so distinctive. After the first line“I’m not a ladies man, I’m a landmine” you’re completely hooked. By now I couldn’t care less about genre, this just works. It’s hip-hop without guns and bitches, it’s hip-hop you can sing along to. Not only that, but it’s incredibly indie. Which isn’t a bad thing, I assure you. There’s catchy choruses, hell, this is stuff you can play in clubs. By the time the third track, These Few Presidents, kicks in there’s shivers down my spine. Yoni’s voice echoes alongside a gentle organ and some heavy drum beats, and then the chorus kicks in and I’m singing along. It’s brilliant stuff.
The next track, The Hollows is by far the most accessible track on the album. Distorted guitars gently strummed with the occasional heavy riff, pianos and organs to keep the track together with a simple drum beat that just fits. This song just works on so many levels. I feel this song also epitomises Yoni’s writing style, in that it mixes really direct lyrics that conjures up some pretty grim imagery, and some odd lyrics that you have to go back to to attempt to understand the meaning. There’s some elements of cLOUDDEAD shining through, but the lyrics are a lot less surreal and manageable.
I could go on about every song on this album, because I can’t honestly find one that I don’t find some sort of enjoyment in. Fatalist Palmistry is wonderful and upbeat, and contrasts with the previous tracks, as they are more emotional and somewhat broody. It’s just a really happy song. The Fall Of Mr. Fifths is yet another different song, revolving around minimal drums and odd jingles, with Yoni doing what he does best, until towards the end as the song escalates into a wonderful, lovely, cheery melody that would put a lot of post-rock bands to shame. Finally, I want to talk about By Torpedo or Chron’s, which is by far my favourite song on the album. Straight away the song kicks into a simple yet haunting piano riff, with some minimal drums and Yoni rapping along. But he is rapping about real things, relatable subjects, normal life. The way he describes objects and provokes imagery is outstanding. “My neighbour walks by/High heels click dry/Like half a proud horse down brook” and is consistent throughout the song, and the album for that matter. And then the chorus, which, without sounding too enthusiastic, takes my breath away. It’s fantastic.
So yes, as you can probably tell, I am a massive fan of this album, and Why? for that matter. The great thing about them is that they have fans from all sorts of backgrounds and social groups. Hell, I know people who are heavily into death metal who enjoy some songs. There’s something in it for everyone, it’s incredibly accessible. Which is a good thing, as Yoni’s talent of describing the world is a talent too good to waste. I highly recommend you get this album when possible. You will not regret it.
The Hollows
9.4/10